What is the best alternative to Privy?

It depends on which part of Privy you are replacing. Gamification sits on a higher tier, so the wheel is not the cheap entry point. If that is the reason you are looking, the table above shows which of DealCraft, Wheelio, OptiMonk and Justuno covers it. If it is not, there may be no reason to move.

What is Privy good at?

Popups, email marketing and cart abandonment recovery come from one vendor. It is built for small stores wanting capture, email and cart recovery from one vendor.

Is DealCraft a replacement for Privy?

Only for some of it. DealCraft runs three game mechanics against the larger libraries in this category, so a team that wants many different games is better served elsewhere. It fits where the promotion has to stop at a budget the server enforces, be honoured at a counter rather than an online checkout, or sit inside a product the company already owns.

Why does it matter where the outcome of a spin is decided?

If the browser decides the result, the result can be edited by anyone who opens developer tools, and the promotion can be drained. Deciding on the server before the animation runs means the wheel is showing a result that has already been recorded, so what the player sees and what the business owes are the same thing.

Privy alternatives compared on what actually differs

Popups bundled with email and SMS marketing for small ecommerce teams. Popups, email marketing and cart abandonment recovery come from one vendor. The limitation that usually sends people looking: gamification sits on a higher tier, so the wheel is not the cheap entry point. This page sets Privy beside DealCraft, Wheelio, OptiMonk and Justuno on the rows that decide what a promotion costs and whether its result can be trusted. The verdicts are the ones from the category table, unchanged.

How they compare

Prices verified on 2026-09-19. “Not published” means the vendor does not document the capability either way, not that it is absent.

Privy alternatives compared on what actually differs
Capability	Privy	DealCraft	Wheelio	OptiMonk	Justuno
Outcome decided on the server before the animation runsIf the browser decides who wins, anyone who opens developer tools can change the answer. Deciding server-side first and animating to a result that is already recorded is the difference between a promotion and a liability.	Not published	Yes	Not published	Not published	Not published
Hard cap on how much the promotion can give awayA win rate alone does not bound cost. Without a cap the server enforces, an unusually lucky day is indistinguishable from a bug until the invoice arrives.	Not published	Yes	Not published	Not published	Not published
Staff can mark a reward used at a counterA cafe or salon needs somebody behind the till to confirm a code was honoured. Without it the same screenshot can be redeemed all afternoon.	No	Yes	No	No	No
Runs outside a single storefront platformMost tools in this category are Shopify apps. That is the right answer for a Shopify store and the wrong one for a bank app, a printed QR code, or a site on another stack.	Yes	Yes	Partly	Yes	Yes
API and iframe embed into your own productA team with engineers usually wants the game inside their own app, under their own domain, rather than a popup bolted onto a marketing page.	Not published	Yes	Not published	Partly	Partly
Free tier that runs a real campaignA trial that expires in a week tells you whether the setup is pleasant. A free tier that runs a live campaign tells you whether players actually play.	No	Yes	No	Yes	Yes
Entry price	Gamification from $49/mo	See pricing	From about $14.93/mo	Free, paid from $39/mo	Free, then usage-based
Free tier	No	Yes	No, 7-day trial	Yes, 5,000 page views	Yes, 2,000 visitors

How we compared

Every cell is the one from the category table, not a fresh judgement written for this page. A product does not score differently because the page is named after a competitor.
A capability is only marked missing where the vendor’s own documentation shows it is absent. Where it is simply not documented, it is marked unverified rather than counted against the product.
Prices come from public pricing pages on the verification date below and are entry points, not quotes. Usage-based tiers move with traffic.
DealCraft is one of the products being compared, and its own limitations are listed alongside everyone else’s.

The products in detail

Privy

Popups bundled with email and SMS marketing for small ecommerce teams.

Best for: Small stores wanting capture, email and cart recovery from one vendor.
Pricing: Gamified formats start around $49/mo. No free plan for gamification.
Free tier: No

Strengths

Popups, email marketing and cart abandonment recovery come from one vendor.
Approachable for a small team with no dedicated marketer.

Limitations

Gamification sits on a higher tier, so the wheel is not the cheap entry point.
The game is a lead-capture device; reward economics are not the focus.

Privy website

DealCraft(this is our product)

A capped, server-decided probability engine with attribution, rather than a popup builder that happens to include a wheel.

Best for: Businesses that need the cost of a promotion bounded, and teams running one campaign online and in person.
Pricing: Current plans are listed on the pricing page.
Free tier: Yes

Strengths

Every outcome is decided and recorded server-side before any animation starts.
Win rate and hard reward caps are configured together, which bounds campaign cost.
One configuration serves a printed QR code, a hosted link and an iframe in your product.
Counter staff mark a reward used through a PIN-protected link, so a code cannot be spent twice.

Limitations

Not a general popup or email suite: no exit-intent library, no newsletter sending, no cart-abandonment flow.
Newer product with a smaller integration catalogue than the established Shopify apps.

DealCraft website

Wheelio

The best-known spin-to-win popup app, focused on Shopify storefronts.

Best for: Shopify stores that want a proven wheel popup with minimal setup.
Pricing: Four tiers, roughly $14.93 to $109.92 per month. No free plan; 7-day trial.
Free tier: No, 7-day trial

Strengths

Long track record and a large template library for the wheel format specifically.
Strong Shopify integration and a low entry price.

Limitations

No free plan, so the mechanic cannot be tested on real traffic before paying.
Built around the online storefront, not in-person redemption.

Wheelio website

OptiMonk

A broad popup and conversion suite where gamification is one format of many.

Best for: Teams wanting gamification plus exit-intent, surveys and recommendations in one tool.
Pricing: Gamification is on the free plan up to 5,000 page views; paid from $39/mo at 20,000 page views.
Free tier: Yes, 5,000 page views

Strengths

Spin-to-win, scratch-off and mystery gift are all available, including on the free plan.
Goes well beyond games: exit-intent, cart abandonment, sticky bars, surveys, recommendations.

Limitations

Design customisation of the game formats is more limited than dedicated wheel apps.
Priced on page views, which couples cost to traffic rather than to rewards given.

OptiMonk website

Justuno

Conversion platform whose strength is targeting and segmentation rules.

Best for: Stores that want games layered on top of sophisticated audience targeting.
Pricing: Free up to 2,000 visitors per month; paid tiers add traffic capacity and advanced features.
Free tier: Yes, 2,000 visitors

Strengths

Spin to win, scratch and reveal, slot machines and mystery offers are all standard.
Advanced targeting logic is the real differentiator, not the game itself.

Limitations

The free tier is small enough that a busy store passes it quickly.
Targeting depth carries a learning curve for an operator without a marketing team.

Justuno website

Questions people ask

What is the best alternative to Privy?: It depends on which part of Privy you are replacing. Gamification sits on a higher tier, so the wheel is not the cheap entry point. If that is the reason you are looking, the table above shows which of DealCraft, Wheelio, OptiMonk and Justuno covers it. If it is not, there may be no reason to move.
What is Privy good at?: Popups, email marketing and cart abandonment recovery come from one vendor. It is built for small stores wanting capture, email and cart recovery from one vendor.
Is DealCraft a replacement for Privy?: Only for some of it. DealCraft runs three game mechanics against the larger libraries in this category, so a team that wants many different games is better served elsewhere. It fits where the promotion has to stop at a budget the server enforces, be honoured at a counter rather than an online checkout, or sit inside a product the company already owns.
Why does it matter where the outcome of a spin is decided?: If the browser decides the result, the result can be edited by anyone who opens developer tools, and the promotion can be drained. Deciding on the server before the animation runs means the wheel is showing a result that has already been recorded, so what the player sees and what the business owes are the same thing.